Tom Murry
5 months ago
Game is fixed. Once you have won so many games in a row, you start getting matched up with usernames like CPU1 and other usernames that are clearly Bots where no matter what your player score is, head-to-head matchups you will almost always lose 5 to 4. The fact that you repeatedly get the same five or six player cards doesn't really help but forces you to play more which I understand is what developers want. More than anything this game is a bunch of guessing and requires very little skill
Jordan Carrillo
5 months ago
This game makes zero sense you can only do so many plays and you have to work with odds like only a 20 percent chance to get a play. But the thing that trips me out is I have missed a play on a 90% like 5 times and they get a play when it's on 10% because it can't go lower or higher than 10% or 90% but if they can hit off a 10 I should at least be able to make it off a 45% but no even then it's a guaranteed loss play I'm just confused and honestly don't wanna play it anymore
E Healy
5 months ago
Highly enjoyable card based football game. Kinda addictive. It's still early in the games development, but it's getting better all the time. Excited to see where it goes. The 'fantasy' style game planned for the regular NFL season should be interesting.
G Rodriguez
4 months ago
This game's animations are great, need more. Have an auction site to buy and sell players and playbooks, need a lot more plays with chances for it to become a big play, like broken tackles or touchdown, etc. But I like it, keep tweaking this game. Great job
Christopher Eitel
6 months ago
It's fun but the percentages are flawed. My opponent should not be able to easily make big gains if the percentage is 17%. Either rethink the percentage situation or just make the game like WWE SuperCard. It would be easier and more accessible for people. Just my opinion. Too many issues to recommend at this state. Oh yeah they have been constantly making awful changes. Like before you could get 75 silver tokens for fully leveled players you pull. Now you only get 50.
videogamenerdify
4 months ago
Cool idea, poor execution. Repetitive coin flip simulator even when achieving an almost full bar of success on an attempt you will still lose 80% of the time. Friend bought some in-game currency and his chances of getting a successful play off significantantly increased. Another cash grab dumpster of a game
Phatboi Ent
6 months ago
Fun to play when it's actually fun, other times the unrealistic RNG ruins the fun. I could have 85+% offense chance and fail and have less than 20% chance and still somehow succeed. Also the AI in the game is broke, they can easily predict what you do on offense plus some parts of the playbook sometimes give pass only or run only plays so the AI can easily block it. Game has potential to be strategically fun, just don't make it all about Pay to Win and unrealistic scenarios. Keen to see more!
StuartTheYoutuber
4 months ago
Man this app has a couple of good points, one or two negatives and a feature that I think needs adding. Pros : Doesn't feel like a massive pay to win. I like some of the animations and they got rid of the percentage outcome which was infuriating. Cons : Talking of animations, could do with more variation, I would like to see an auction added so you could build out your roster a bit more but not essential. Would like : I am begging for a desktop version of this, maybe through Steam?
James Long
5 months ago
I really want to like this game but I just can't. This was an extremely lazy effort by 2k. Atleast 100 matches played and the animations are slow , boring and extremely repetitive . There aren't any interception or fumble animations from what I've seen . I had to fight the urge to pay for a pack or 2 to see if pay 2 win would improve the experience but the experience is so poor that I don't even deem it worth it . Come better or don't come at all 2k . EA disappoints us enough already .
brandon sita
5 months ago
Ill keep this review pretty straight forward. Game is good. Very rewarding. I get good players often. But DO NOT have me pick a play, and tell me offense has a 90% chance to succeed or opposing offense has 10%, and I will fail due to picking the wrong play. Its a 33% for each play but depends on what opposing team does. Completely based on picking what the game deems as the "correct" play is how to win. Percentages dont mean squat.
Sodawingy 12
6 months ago
I think this game as a concept can work, but there needs to be more outcomes or choices for plays. Maybe for defense, you get 5-6 options that are designed for short , medium, and long plays. Maybe something like play action can gain extra yards if run blitz is called. The rng in general never really feels accurate, and it seems way easier for defense to succeed than offense.
Keith Stegmaier
5 months ago
Throwing darts blindfolded in a tornado would be more accurate than the success rate of this simulation. Do not spend money. Many 90 (would be higher but capped), 81, 73, etc % success fails miserably. Not only that but individual players 500+ rating higher. Nope. Playing D, the opponent success rate 20% or less, even 10% and again outranked. They make it. There is too much luck. It pains me because this is the type of football sim I e been looking for (coaching. Not player control)
Nick M
6 months ago
Outside of the Ultimate Team feeling of packing cards, this game has a lot of issues. Limiting plays, not playing to win games, but completing objectives instead, percentages are horrible off, made more 50% or less plays than j have 90. Capping at 10% and 90% is stupid. No ability to intercept, fumble, or any type of turn over beside on downs. Many things need to be fixed for this to get even a 2 star.
Nicholas Gervasi
5 months ago
I like the concept of this game, but percentage of success either on offense or defense needs to be fixed. 90% (capped) success rate on offense shouldn't be failing more times than anything below 50%. Also if I choose the right defense and the opposing offense success is at 10%, they mostly convert it more times than I would if I had 90 % on offense. Needs to be balanced more and make more sense
Kevin Tibbett
5 months ago
I actually really enjoy this game and would go 5 stars once the field goal operation is fixed, I have lost so many games I shouldn't have lost because that chooses not to work. I actually here the button click register but the meter just keeps moving on it own. When this is fixed I will rate 5 stars. The only reason I am rating so low is I hope the devs fix this issue, or at least give an option for a swipe kick. That way if I mess up it's on me, not because it chooses not to work right.
Elijah Moh
6 months ago
The game is fun with collecting players. But translating the skills of each player into the gameplay is horrendous. I figured this game is in its early developmental stages so I gave it some time for possible updates, but nothing. Suggestion: plays should have a range of yards, not a set range of yards. Percentages should be more realistic.
Midnight Edition
6 months ago
It was fun at first, but then the matchups became very unfair. They put you up against teams that have cards twice as good as yours in season 2 of seasons, and the computer picks your play every time, making it impossible to get any yards. Just like every other game, they let you win in the beginning to make it impossible afterward, forcing you to spend money.
Tommy Wheeler
5 months ago
Fun game. Great idea. Main problem I've seen is is seasons where you have to do 'Rush Attack' but 2 or 3 times in a row it only lets you chose a pass play. When you get 3 first downs in a row, you never have a chance to do 4 rush attempts. Please give 1 extra play to the pool for better odds or guarantee 1 pass and 1 run play in the selection every time.
Nicholas Ramoser
5 months ago
It's fun and a way to pass the time. But the whole percentage thing is a scam. I've been scored on more times on defense when the opposing team has a 10% chance of success. I have the percentage on my side and better players with boosts and skills. Also, ironically I've been shut down multiple times on offense when I have a 90% chance to win and be successful, with better players with skills and boosts. Too inconsistent and the game has issues with that and they need to fix it.
Robert Jures
4 months ago
Been at it for almost 3 weeks and the playcalling and the chances make 0 sense to me. What is the point of getting plays into the blue and green range for them to fail way more often then should. Good thing I can make FGs when thats all that is needed to win a game. Then when on defense unless its impossible to complete they succeed way more often. Kills motivation to try and complete things. Will stick it out for next event and see if things improve